Tons of grooming options promise softness or a healthier beard look, but the real struggle is finding one that delivers on all fronts—softness, shine, and overall beard health.
We’ve curated a list of the best beard butter that fit these three criteria, complete with their pros, cons, and ratings.
Jump Links
- That Urban Edge Beard Butter
- Live Bearded Beard Butter
- Grave Before Shave Beard Butter
- Wild Willies Beard Butter
- Beard Guyz Beard Butter
- Every Man Jack Beard Butter
- Detroit Grooming Co. Beard Butter
- Maestro’s Classic Beard Butter
- Beard Octane Liquid Gold Beard Butta
- Bossman Jelly Beard Oil
- Softsheen-Carson Beard Butter
- Fresh Beards ‘Black Light’ Beard Butter
- Oak City Beard Company Beard Butter
1. That Urban Edge Beard Butter
If you need beard butter to tame your unruly beard, That Urban Edge is a solid choice. Infused with Shea Butter and Argan Oil, it deeply hydrates, softens, and adds a healthy shine.
Its rich formula also helps boost thickness and volume, giving your beard a fuller look. Most importantly, it fights dryness, beardruff, and acne, keeping both your beard and skin in top shape.
Price: $12.99 per 2 Oz. You can get it on Amazon
Pros
- Formulated with natural butter and oils
- Boost beard growth
- Gentle on the skin and prevents acne
- Adds volume and thickness to the beard
- Leaves the beard soft, shiny, and healthy
- It is non-greasy and non-comedogenic
- Prevents itchiness, dryness, and dandruff
- Formulated for all kinds of beard
Cons
- Limited stock
Rating: 4.9/5
2. Live Bearded Beard Butter
One popular thing about Live Bearded beard butter is the variation of scents. There are 6 different sweet manly scents to choose from and one unscented variation in case you get reactions from using scented products.
The Live Bearded beard butter is made from a mixture of Shea Butter, Coconut Oil, Jojoba Oil, and other nourishing oils. These ingredients offer conditioning benefits while adding softness and shine to your beard.
Price: $20 per 3 Oz.
Pros
- Multiple scent options to choose from
- Offers light-to-medium hold
Cons
- Multiple scent options might be confusing for first-time users
- Might be pricey for people on a tight budget
Rating: 4/5
3. Grave Before Shave Beard Butter
The Grave Before Shave beard butter is another brand with about 10 scent options and an impressive list of natural ingredients, including Shea Butter, Mango Butter, Coconut Oil, and Argan Oil.
These ingredients nourish the beard and offer conditioning benefits. It’s also a solid option for fighting beardruff and itchiness.
There’s also an unscented option if you’re not a fan of strong beard fragrances.
Price: $22.99 per 4 Oz.
Pros
- Offers less drag when brushing or combing the beard
- Anti-itch
- Nourishes and conditions the beard
Cons
- A bit expensive
Rating: 4.3/5
4. Wild Willies Beard Butter
The Wild Willies beard butter comes in only two scented options and one unscented option. Similar to others on the list, it is packed with natural essential oils that will leave your beard with a matte finish.
This beard butter is also a great option if you’re looking for a product to add moisture and softness to your beard.
Price: $10 per 2 Oz.
Pros
- Cheap to buy
- Not greasy and easily applicable
Cons
- Not efficient for beardruff and itchiness
Rating: 3.5/5
5. Beard Guyz Beard Butter
The Beard Guyz beard butter is a natural conditioner packed with ingredients like cocoa butter, coconut oils, and mango butter to moisturize each beard strand.
Meanwhile, natural oils like jojoba oil and argan oil slap in some shine and soothing benefits. It also fights against itchiness and beardruff. The scent is subtle but leaves a lasting impression.
Price: $13.49 per 4 Oz.
Pros
- Anti-itch
- Nourishes and boosts beard growth
- Comes in cheap for its size
Cons
- Doesn’t add volume or thickness to the beard
Rating: 4.2/5
6. Every Man Jack Beard Butter
The Every Man Jack beard butter combines star natural ingredients like Shea and Cocoa butter to soften hair, condition beards, and tame flyaways. It also comes in three scented and one unscented option.
Price: $12 per 4 Oz.
Pros
- Multiple scent options
- Comes in cheap for its size
Cons
- Not effective for preventing itchiness and beardruff
- Doesn’t add volume and thickness
Rating: 4.3/5
7. Detroit Grooming Co. Beard Butter
The Detroit Grooming Co. beard butter contains Shea butter, Safflower Oil, and Avocado Oil, which condition your beard and promote hair growth.
It also moisturizes the skin underneath your beard and gives a light hold to provide a natural look. The product comes in five scent options.
Price: $15.95 per 2 Oz.
Pros
- Multiple scent options
- Promotes hair growth
- Adds thickness and volume to the beard
Cons
- Not effective for preventing itchiness and beardruff
Rating: 4.1/5
8. Maestro’s Classic Beard Butter
Maestro’s Classic beard butter is a water-based product with two elegant scent options and one unscented option. It features a mix of Coconut oil, Cocoa seed butter, and glycerine to keep your beard hydrated and shiny.
The butter also softens dry, unruly beards and prevents itchiness.
Price: The Mark of a Man scent goes for $7.99 per 2 Oz, while the Speakeasy Blend scent and the unscented variation cost $13.99 per 4 Oz.
Pros
- Softens unruly beards and tames flyaways
- Multiple scent options
- Prevents itchiness and dryness
Cons
- Confusing prices and sizes depending on scent options
- Doesn’t add volume and thickness to the beard
Rating: 4.1/5
9. Beard Octane Liquid Gold Beard Butta
The Beard Octane Liquid Gold beard butter features Shea butter and natural oils to moisturize the beard and skin underneath while adding zero grease due to its light texture. Its hydration properties help to prevent dryness, flakiness, and itchiness.
Price: $24.99 per 4 Oz.
Pros
- Tames flyaways
- Not greasy
- Multiple scent option
Cons
- Doesn’t add volume or thickness to the beard
- A bit expensive
Rating: 4.0/5
10. Bossman Jelly Beard Oil
The Bossman Jelly beard oil is a lotion gel, and it comes in 13 unique scent options. Constituent ingredients like beeswax, avocado oil, and soybean oil help add thickness and volume to thin beards while boosting beard growth and health.
Price: $17.95 per 4 Oz.
Pros
- Tames flyaways
- Multiple scent options
- Easy to apply since it’s a lotion
- Not greasy
Cons
- Adds weight to the beard if overapplied because of Beeswax
- Too many options to choose from
- Not effective for itchiness and beardruff
Rating: 4.0/5
11. Softsheen-Carson Beard Butter
The Softsheen-Carson beard butter offers moisturizing and softening benefits thanks to the combination of natural ingredients like Cocoa butter and Cedarwood oil. And it has a characteristic, manly scent.
Its conditioning benefits also make it a great choice for unruly and textured or coarse beards.
Price: $7.49 per 3.4 Oz.
Pros
- Not greasy
- It is cheap for its size
Cons
- Doesn’t add volume or thickness to the beard
- Not effective for preventing itchiness and beardruff
Rating: 4.0/5
12. Fresh Beards ‘Black Light’ Beard Butter
The Fresh Beards Black Light beard butter has 15 scent options and features shea butter, coconut, jojoba, almond, and grapeseed. These ingredients work together to condition and moisturize the beard and fight itchiness and beardruff.
Price: $19.99 per 4 Oz.
Pros
- Anti-itch
- Good for sensitive skin
- Not greasy
Cons
- Doesn’t add volume and thickness
- Too many scent options
Rating: 4.5/5
13. Oak City Beard Company Beard Butter
The Oak City Beard Company beard butter contains a mixture of safflower oil, jojoba oil, coconut oil, and castor oil. Its star ingredient is Shea butter, while Beeswax and Vitamin E provide hold and extra nourishment.
This 14-scented butter is ideal if you’re craving a luxurious feel. It also conditions the beard and fights against itchiness and dryness.
Price: $10.88 per 2 Oz.
Pros
- Anti-itch
- Cost affordable
Cons
- Might be heavy on the beard if overapplied because of Beeswax
- Too many scent options to choose from
Rating: 3.9/5
Conclusion
An ideal beard butter should be able to soften and moisturize your strands, tame the flyaways, give a lasting hold, and still come cheap or within your budget. That Urban Edge beard butter checks all these boxes to help you always keep your confident look.
To maximize your beard growth, you can also get a full beard grooming combo here.